Not A Feesh NAF (LYE) 2‑Part: Is the pH Benefit Worth the Dangers of Sodium Hydroxide?
Not A Feesh, or simply NAF, stands out as a sodium hydroxide-based two-part additive. It offers double the pH lift compared to most other two-part systems on the market. This makes it a powerful tool for reefers dealing with chronically low pH (below 7.8) or those who are "pro-level" and aim for peak performance, like maintaining an 8.3 pH in an rapid growth Acropora tank.
NAF sodium hydroxide based 2 part
Claim to Fame
NAF’s headline: it’s a sodium hydroxide based two part alkalinity system that raises pH more aggressively than carbonate‑based two‑parts. The chemistry doubles the pH lift over common soda ash based 2 parts because hydroxide reacts with dissolved CO2 in your tank to form carbonate alkalinity and reduces carbonic acid. Practically, that means a stronger upward push on pH compared to sodium carbonate or bicarbonate approaches.
Note: Paid YouTube SR Members Using A Chrome Browser can watch videos natively above on Seriousreefs.com. Sign up HERE
SR videos are a community funded member only resource. Serious Reefs buys everything we review, accepts no sponsorships, and your memberships make it possible to keep every review truly unfiltered.
Who Is NAF For?
If your reef tank consistently struggles with low pH (chronically under ~7.8) — especially in sealed houses, small apartments, or high‑CO2 environments — this is a solution worth considering. If you’re a pro‑level reefer with a moderate pH (around 8.0) who isn’t happy with growth rates or success rates with more sensitive corals, it’s also in the conversation.
Research: Sodium hydroxide (lye) was confirmed to have double the pH lift of soda ash in this video. In this experiment coral grew 29% faster at a pH of 8.3 than 7.8. Results were over a 3 month period. This suggests the compounding growth many be as much as double to triple annually. Results match similar studies on the effects of excess carbon dioxide and ocean acidification on natural coral reefs.
pH Below 7.8 Can Stress Coral & Stunt Growth
pH ~8.3 Produces Natural Growth Rates
Price and What You Get
The kit we evaluated is competitively priced at $45 for a two gallon set. The SR standardized concentration cost is $17.12*. That price point includes magnesium, potassium and a blend of trace/minor elements, which puts it among the lower cost options once you factor in “complete kit” pricing. NAF is offered in both liquid concentrate (viscous, syrup‑like) and dry forms (no trace) on the vendor’s site; the liquid concentrate is diluted in water and mixes easily.
NAF Concentration: 6,945 DKH/L
NAF Cost: $45.00 for 1 gallon set of solution.
10,000 DKH/L Standard: $17.12
*SR has developed a standardized cost for two part because You’re not paying for water, you’re paying for the salts dissolved in it. The SR Standardized Concentration Cost (SR-SCC) levels the playing field by calculating cost based on a standardized concentration of 10,000 dKH per liter. In short, SR-SCC shows how much of any reviewed additive is required to reach that same 10,000 dKH per-liter equivalent, making it easier to evaluate what you are really getting for your money.
Chemistry: How NAF Works (and how it compares)
Basic idea: The hydroxide (OH−) reacts with CO2 in the reef tank water, pulling CO2 out of the dissolved carbonic acid phase and converting it into carbonate alkalinity (CO3 2−) for your corals. That removed carbonic acid from the carbonate system, results in a meaningful pH increase and raises alkalinity.
Compared to kalkwasser (calcium hydroxide): kalk gives a similar mechanism but is far less concentrated, meaning you need much more volume to get the same effect. It is not uncommon to dose 4,000 ml a day of kalkwasser. NAF, being sodium hydroxide based, is much more concentrated and the dose can commonly be as little as 40ml a day.
The NAF formulation also claims to manage magnesium, potassium, and traces. NAF accounts for both coral uptake of major, minor, and trace elements as well as the effects of salinity increases and dilution steps required for salt based two parts. Like every blended additive, these balances are an approximation; a regular water change schedule will buffer the differences between estimated science and real world results. Annual ICP tests can be used to confirm long term results.
Safety: The Big Conversation You Can’t Skip
NAF is not “dangerous” if handled correctly, but it does require real respect. Sodium hydroxide is a strong base: skin contact, eye contact, and ingestion are serious hazards. Compared to other two‑parts, it’s in a different category of risk.
Packaging & Labeling Concerns
Current packaging includes warnings, but our view is the labeling could be considerably stronger. Industry analogs (drain cleaners, commercial lyes) typically show aggressive hazard icons, “fatal if swallowed” language, and explicit federal style warnings. For a product like this, we’d expect:
Clear hazard pictograms (corrosive/poison) and "Fatal if swallowed" style wording
Childproof caps and tamper seals
Double heat‑sealed or heavy duty bagging for liquid bottles
Robust, leak‑resistant packaging designed for UPS and Fedex shipments
Instructions — please make them specific
Current directions we saw read: “Add the entire contents of part two to a container that holds one gallon, add enough water to a gallon, stir gently, shake to combine.” The instructions direct you to “pour NAF Strong Base concentrate in, then add water” — which is backwards for strong bases. Best‑practice: always add the strong base to water (slowly), never the reverse. A step‑by‑step instructions with proper safety language coupled with an instructional video demonstrating the process would be ideal.
Personal protective equipment (PPE)
Use chemical splash goggles (not just safety glasses) — goggles protect from fumes and splashes.
Wear appropriate chemical‑resistant gloves and long sleeves; consider arm‑high gloves for extra protection.
Work on an easy‑to‑clean surface and have fresh water for irrigation available.
Uline Safety Goggles
$17 Uline Showa® Atlas® 772 Chemical Resistant Nitrile Gloves
Shipping limitations
Strong acids and bases are commonly restricted or prohibited on aircraft (air freight) due to the damage they can cause to aircraft components if they leak. Vendors should follow hazardous material shipping rules and clearly communicate shipping limitations to customers.
Subjective Purity & a Curious Smell
Clarity: the mixed solutions were crystal clear, which is a good sign of quality. The vendor indicates ACS‑grade raw materials for major components (ACS is often considered equal or above USP pharmaceutical grades).
During testing, NAF had a distinct odor. It turned out this smell comes from citric acid, which is listed as an ingredient in the calcium part. The manufacturer explains that citric acid serves two purposes:
Extra Carbon Source: It provides an additional carbon source for carbon dosing, which can help reduce nutrients in the tank.
Trace Element Preservative: It helps preserve the trace elements, extending their shelf life. One of which is likely the Selenomethionine, a amino acid form of selenium found in NAF
This inclusion of carbon dosing is a unique feature. It might appeal to advanced reefers looking for every possible benefit for their corals.
Also, the ingredient ordering on the label looked odd and it did not appear that the elements were listed from most‑to‑least which should be corrected.
Calculator & Switching From Other Systems
NAF’s website includes a practical calculator that helps you convert from other two‑part products. Enter your current daily dose (e.g., 50 mL/day of product X) and it gives you the equivalent NAF volume. That’s a great adoption booster — easy conversions reduce guesswork and make switching less painful.
Not A Feesh Calculator
Ease of Daily Dosing — What You Need
This is a dosing pump product. If you want to use NAF properly, set it up as an automatic, slow drip on a daily doser. Do not attempt to dose this product by hand because hand dosing can cause excess precipitation and large pH swings if done too quickly.
Recommended hardware & configuration
Use a high‑quality dosing pump capable of accurate, small incremental doses (drip style, not “squirt” on/off).
Make sure your dosing pumps internal tubing set is compatible with high pH solutions and sodium hydroxide. Santoprene is listed HERE as one of the better options. Consider extension tubing between the pump and tank as well.
Place a robust AC powerhead in the sump at the point of dosing (~1500 gph) to immediately disperse the dose and avoid localized pH spikes or precipitation.
Monitor pH continuously. You are solving a pH issue with this product which means you need to monitor it closely. Pinpoint and Milwaukee make popular pH monitors.
“Never in a million years would I use this without at least pH monitoring.- Ryan”
Consider a pH controller or aquarium controller which can cut power to the doser if pH gets too high and alert you of the issue.
Unreliable pumps, or “lo‑fi” dosing hacks are not recommended — this formulation’s potency warrants robust controls and monitoring.
Pinpoint pH monitor
Milwaukee pH controller
BRS Doser -Santoprene tubing
Apex Monitor
Adjustments & Periodic Maintenance
You should not use NAF for occasional manual pH adjustments. Its potency makes it unsuitable for quick fixes. If you need to make larger, periodic adjustments to alkalinity or calcium, it is far safer to use separate, dedicated alkalinity and calcium adjusters, such as bicarbonate alkalinity and calcium chloride adjustment tools.
Only affects alkalinity with no material pH change. A good solution for periodic adjustments.
Calcium Chloride - Only affects calcium. Good solution for periodic adjustments
Only affects Magnesium. A good solution for periodic adjustments
Who Should (and Shouldn’t) Use NAF
Recommended for: Innovators and early adopters (the ~3% of reefers who trial new tech), and reefers with real, persistent low pH problems — sealed homes, small apartments with high CO2, or tanks with demanding SPS/acro systems.
Consider carefully: If your pH is stable and healthy, you probably don’t need this. If you don’t want to add monitoring and fail‑safes, don’t use it.
Many reefers in dense urban settings (tight apartments, multi‑occupant homes, gas stoves) can see elevated indoor CO2 enough to depress aquarium pH — NAF and other sodium hydroxide solutions are likely to become the tool of the future to address those environments.
Final Thoughts
NAF is trailblazing in bringing a sodium hydroxide two‑part to retail in the U.S. That’s a big deal for reefers who need extra pH lifting power. The chemistry makes sense, the kit is competitively priced and uses high‑grade inputs, and the vendor included trace elements and a useful calculator to ease switching.
That said, this product demands respect: better labeling, explicit safety instructions, stronger packaging, and clear step‑by‑step mixing guidance (video included) should be non‑negotiables. You should never run NAF without proper dosing hardware and pH monitoring — ideally with a controller that can shut dosing off if pH goes beyond safe limits.
If you’re the type who likes to try new reefing innovations and you have the need and the safeguards in place, this is worth testing. If you’re more conservative or your tank is stable, hold off and watch how the early adopters fare. Either way, be safe, use the right PPE, and monitor closely.
Quicklinks - Items Discussed In This Article.
Avid aqua monitor (Has a version that monitors room Co2)
BRS Doser (Santoprene)
Using these links helps SR earn a small commission, stay unfiltered, and fuels “what’s next” for the SR community. Thank you for the support.
Acknowledgments
Thank you to Terence Fugazzi for researching NAF, traveling to the SR studio, and bringing his expertise to the discussion. Terence is founder of AvidAqua, check them out.
Big thank you to the Serious Reefs community. Your membership funds the creation of articles and videos like this one. Serious reefs maintains it’s unfiltered objectivity by paying for everything we review and never accepting sponsors. We are trail blazing a new way of doing this together
Patreon - Best For Those who…
Want immediate notifications of every release.
Listen with phone screen off. Patreon app works with phone closed
Lower cost & Annual discounts.
Join HERE
YouTube Members - Best For Those who…
Watch SR videos on a TV via youtube App
Want to watch videos natively here on seriousreefs.com - (You must use chrome browser and be logged into google account with youtube membership)
YouTube Power users.
Join HERE
Disclaimer
Full Disclaimer HERE. This is the gist of it.
Serious Reefs has no sponsors, doesn’t accept product or payment reviews.
We’re biased toward what works best. That bias is probably why you’re here.
Content is based on personal experience, not professional advice. Do your research and reef responsibly.
We use affiliate links in articles that earn a small commission to support our work. Shop wherever you like, we won’t be offended.
By watching, you agree that Serious Reefs and its creators aren’t liable for how you use this info. Please don’t utilize our information if you are not ok with this.
Pyramid ButterflyFish: Fish 101
The Pyramid Butterflyfish (Hemitaurichthys polylepis) is a reef-safe standout — a butterflyfish that breaks the rules. Unlike most of its cousins, it won’t pick at corals or invertebrates, making it a true exception in the butterflyfish world. This makes it a top choice for reef tank owners looking for the elegant swimming style and striking appearance of a butterflyfish without the worry of them eating corals or invertebrates.
A Reef-Safe Jewel for Your Reef Tank
Pyramid ButterflyFish
The Pyramid Butterflyfish (Hemitaurichthys polylepis) is a reef-safe standout — a butterflyfish that breaks the rules. Unlike most of its cousins, it won’t pick at corals or invertebrates, making it a true exception in the butterflyfish world. This makes it a top choice for reef tank owners looking for the elegant swimming style and striking appearance of a butterflyfish without the worry of them eating corals or invertebrates.
Note: Paid YouTube SR Members Using A Chrome Browser can watch videos natively above on Seriousreefs.com. Sign up HERE
SR videos are a community funded member only resource. Serious Reefs buys everything we review, accepts no sponsorships, and your memberships make it possible to keep every review truly unfiltered.
At a glance
Common name: Pyramid Butterflyfish
Diet: Plankton/water-column feeder (accepts pellets, Mysis, brine)
Reef-safe: Yes — does not pick at corals or invertebrates
Temperament: Very low aggression; generally peaceful
Tank requirements: Emphasis on swimming space — roughly 4–6 feet of swim room (length or height)
Care level: Easy if healthy; can be challenging if afflicted by protozoans/bacterial infections
What do Pyramid ButterflyFish eat and are they reef safe?
The Pyramid Butterflyfish is a true water-column/plankton feeder. In the wild they live off reef drop-offs and spend their time well above the structure, feeding on plankton rather than grazing surfaces. That natural diet and eating behavior is the reason they’re considered reef-safe. pyramid’s typically won’t nip at corals or pick at invertebrates.
In an aquarium they’re not picky. They readily accept prepared foods: pellets, Mysis shrimp, and brine shrimp are all eaten without much trouble. A simple feeding routine of Mysis once or twice a day will keep them happy and healthy.
Utilitarian behaviors?
These fish do not have much utilitarian value and primarily kept for aesthetics. They add striking white and yellow coloration and graceful movement in the open water column. They don’t perform a cleaning or pest-control function. Reefers like them because of the decorative and behavioral traits, filling the mid-water with motion and color.
How many Pyramids in one tank?
Pyramid Butterflyfish are unusually peaceful for butterflyfish. You can keep multiple individuals together without significant aggression concerns — mix and match sizes if you like. That said, don’t expect captive fish to have schooling behavior the way you would see in the wild; most fish don’t form tight schools in home aquaria because tank conditions change natural predator/prey responses.
If you want more than one, go for it. It’s rare to encounter serious inter-fish aggression with this species. If you’re introducing them to a tank with known aggressive species, an isolation box during acclimation is a sensible precaution, but most folks won’t need it.
Tank size, shape, and aquascape
Because they live and feed in open water, Pyramid Butterflyfish don’t require complex rockwork or heavy aquascaping. What matters most is open, uninterrupted swimming space. I recommend tanks with roughly four to six feet of swim distance — that can be horizontal length or vertical height. They do famously well in tall or column-style displays and are commonly used in public aquarium exhibits for that reason.
Typical home setups that work well include tanks in the 120–180 gallon range (or larger) with ample open water. Focus on creating a clear mid-water corridor rather than packing every inch with structure.
Quarantine, common health issues, and treatments
One of the most important considerations with Pyramid Butterflyfish is susceptibility to protozoan infections (commonly observed as Uronema-like outbreaks) and secondary bacterial infections. Because these problems can progress quickly, a strong quarantine and proactive approach makes a huge difference.
Use a thorough quarantine protocol (SRQT) to observe and address issues you can’t see at first glance.
Be proactive with treatments if you suspect protozoans or bacteria — these fish generally tolerate common medications well.
Isolation boxes are an option for aggressive community tanks, but often introduction without an isolation is fine if your tankmates are peaceful.
In Elliot’s experience, ozone systems in a hospital tank can help some individuals fight off protozoan outbreaks — it’s an approach he has used successfully. That said, ozone, dosing, and quarantine setups require caution and experience.
Skill-level summary: if you avoid protozoan/bacterial outbreaks, Pyramid Butterflyfish are quite hardy and beginner-friendly. If they’re fighting an active infection, care can become advanced — treatment and supportive care can raise the difficulty significantly.
Availability and sourcing for Pyramid ButterflyFish
Pyramid Butterflyfish aren’t available year-round in most markets. They tend to come in seasonal shipments and, when available, often arrive in batches (anywhere from a few dozen to around 100). Because availability can be unpredictable, if you spot a healthy specimen you like, it’s often best to pull the trigger rather than wait.
Buy from reputable sources, pay attention to quarantine history, and ask about recent health and shipping practices. A healthy-looking fish that’s been through a proper QT is the best way to avoid nasty surprises once it’s in your display.
Final thoughts
If you want a reef-safe butterflyfish that brings color and calm movement to the mid-water column, the Pyramid Butterflyfish is a strong candidate. It eats easily, tolerates common aquarium conditions, and gets along with most tankmates — provided you’re vigilant about quarantine and proactive about protozoan/bacterial risks.
They’re not utility fish; they’re showpieces. If that’s what you want, they’ll reward you with elegance and reliability. And if you’ve enjoyed this overview, stick around — next up I’ll dive into the world of dartfish and what makes them so popular in marine setups.
“This is actually one of the only reef safe butterfly fish.”
Acknowledgments
Thank you to Elliot Lim for traveling to the SR studio, and sharing decades of experience. Elliot owns and operates Marinecollectors.com
Thank you to Oral Seymour for capturing the critical information found this video and summarizing it for the reefing community.
Big thank you to the Serious Reefs community. Your membership funds the creation of articles and videos like this one. Serious reefs maintains it’s unfiltered objectivity by paying for everything we review and never accepting sponsors. We are trail blazing a new way of doing this together
Support SR Through Patreon
Best option If you…
Want to discuss with the SR community and ask questions.
Want immediate notifications of every release.
Listen with phone screen off. Patreon app works with phone closed
Want Lower cost & Annual discounts.
Support SR Through YouTube Memberships
Best option If you…
Watch SR videos on a TV via youtube App
Want to watch videos natively here on seriousreefs.com - (You must use chrome browser and be logged into google account with youtube membership)
Are a YouTube power user.